Categories
Entirely True

Holy Saturday

Let me preface this entry by saying that only Roy Wood wished it could be Christmas every day.

I’ve heard a lot of discussion about today – usually involving phrases such as “resurrection people”, “Sunday’s coming” and “sure and certain hope”. None of which fills me with the intended joy and reassurance.

I don’t know too much about church traditions concerning Holy Saturday – except concerning the Harrowing of Hell (what Jesus is said to have done whilst he was resting in peace) and that most of the disciples, having slunk off and abandoned him already must have been feeling in a pretty sorry state.

Lent itself is six weeks of reflection and preparation leading up to Passiontide, and jumping straight from Good Friday to Easter Sunday morning seems to me akin to ripping open our Christmas presents before they’ve even been put under the tree.

Our best friend, leader and only hope has been cruelly murdered, we’re in fear for our own lives and there’s no light at the end of the tunnel – we’re lost and utterly without hope. I, for one, am grateful that the church allows one day a year to commemorate the lost, hopeless confusion that many of us find to be the staples of our every day life.

4 replies on “Holy Saturday”

Thanks Rachel, I guessed that was more or less the reason you tweeted him – and that’s exactly the reason I tweeted you back: so that anybody who’d been following would have a better answer than the three curt lines that you got.

I agree that expecting people to behave in any particular fashion, with no reason given except ‘that’s the whole point, d’uh!’ is a trifle condescending and offputting…

Oh Timbo, WHY would you get ‘I wish it could be Christmas every daaaaay’ in my head, WHY. Do you really want to hurt me? (Do you really want to make me cry-y, wah-wah-wah-waaaaah ) &c.

FWIW I agree with your point – it’s good not to always be or implicitly insist on happy-happy shiney-shiney and we-can’t-say-anything-negative-because-God’s-sovereign-therefore-anything-else-is-rejection-of-truth, absolutely, and maybe it’s good to have a day or two devoted to reflecting that and the fact it’s a legit part of faith. I’m glad to have further discovered this tradition in recent years.

The reason I tweeted @ Giles Fraser yesterday asking him to explain about not being ‘happy’ on Holy Saturday was because someone had RTd his tweet (saying ‘Some Christians really find it a problem to have a day of desolation. They want permanently to be that Phrarrell [sic] Williams Happy video.’ ) into my timeline and it annoyed me. I thought about it and I think I worked out why. It wasn’t that I disagreed with his point; I like the idea of having a day acknowledging the confusion familiar to many and the dark before the dawn. It was just the way he said it. I was trying to gently point out that not everyone (even fellow Christians, and probably many of those who he was getting at) will have been educated in the Holy Week etiquette he was advocating, certainly I never was explicitly, and I grew up in I think a fairly MOTR C of E church.
And, in view of his platform, and in light of the fact that he essentially said ‘you’re doing it wrong, happy clappies’ and left it at that, I thought it might be kinder, fairer and more generous to explain his point of view rather than just saying ‘stop it’ to those rejoicing in what is the all-season Good News on a certain day of the Anglican calendar (which not everyone adheres to strictly). Otherwise it smacks a bit of an attitude of ‘oh you silly other Christians, you just don’t get it [like I do]’, without a sincere desire to put to ‘them’ (whoever he meant; someone on the AB of C’s staff I think primarily) his different perspective. But I don’t know if that came across in what I said. Ho hum.

(This is not a criticism of your post, just an explanation in case you were wondering, as you tweeted me a link to this from my reply to him. I wish Giles would be a bit less snide towards evangelicals particularly, it gets on my wick when people do that [to anyone who believes different, really].)

Anyway, yes, good post, I’ll shut up now. Happy Easter!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.