Thanks to Jonny Arnold for this serious topic which needs addressing for all our sanity. It is of course a trick question.
Whilst pirates may currently be in vogue thanks to the popularity of a certain father-snorting-legendary-and-very-old-guitarist-impersonating-as-a-pirate-captain couple of performances from one Mr Paradis, ninjas have been around a lot longer – but due to their mostly hidden ways they haven’t had half as much exposure as pirates. Technically, as fashion swings constantly between wild-bohemian-anything-goes-ness to all-in-black-ness, at any one point in time the coolness of the pirates and ninjas changes respectively.
The trickiness in this question comes from the (much-disputed) existence of Piranjas – the we’re-bored-of-being-the-deadliest-killing-force-in-all-ninjadom-brigade from way back when who put to sea and really did leave no survivors (which is why most people have never heard of them). They operated around Bermuda for a while, picked the Marie Celeste clean, and are largely responsible for every sea-based mystery disappearence since long before sliced bread.
So, whatever the relative merits of pirates and ninja, it’s clear that Piranjas are much better than either of them.