Categories
Blogathon 2013

The Benefits of Having Two Popes

or three archbishops
(subject courtesy of Clark MacFarlane)

The United Kingdom, home of the Church of England, has three Archbishops (at least) and it doesn’t seem to have it much harm.

Having more than one Arch-anything confuses me, arch meaning top, best, mostest, et c. You couldn’t really have more than one Arch-Nemesis. I guess it must be that Archbishop of Canterbury is the top bishop in all of Canterbury. Given that he’s also the top-most pinnacle of bishopocity, I wonder if, when the archbishops (of their respective regions) gather together, he is hailed as the arch-archbishop?

I know it’s not really like that – and our current ABC has gone record as saying that he’s very glad his position isn’t anything like that of pope.

Speaking of which, there are at least two – but I assume, and somewhat hope, that you mean “two popes of the same church” and from here on in, I’ll use pope to mean Roman Catholic pope. In history, when there have been two popes, this hasn’t been good news for anybody, except the enemies of the church who want to see it destabilised. Having an old, retired pope hanging around isn’t quite as bad as having two actual concurrent (fighting) popes and if Benny’s willing to hang around and give Frankie the benefit of his wisdom rather than spend the rest of his years lying on a beach somewhere, then it probably still wouldn’t be that helpful after the end of a settling-in period.

In the longer term, however, the idea that pope-ness is not always a life-long engagement I think is a healthy one that will allow grace to enter where before there was the assumption of law, which is always something to be celebrated.

22 replies on “The Benefits of Having Two Popes”

I almost cracked that gag but Frankie and Benny are a pair of American Italian restaurateurs. Ben and Jerry (and there was no way I could make the new guy a Jerry) are the ice-cream loving hippies…

One pope could be kept in the garage, always valeted. You could take him to classic bishop shows where you put him out in the park, drink tea out of a thermos flask and answer questions about your pope from the general public.

“This pope is from the early 60’s. I restored him myself. It was really difficult to get the replacement buttons for his cassock but there’s a company down south who had some new old stock”

Duly edited.
I like the idea of a Classic Bishops Show – lots of potential.

Excellent Tim and love the ending. Totally agree! I am a bit concerned though that you might now be –Tim if I use the logic that those above us are +++………!

Cheers
—Clark

Then again, if the pope is Servant of the Servants of God, and we are called to serve, the +++s are below us…

And the UK has lots of archbishops –
in the C of E there is Canterbury (Primate of All England) and York (Primate of England) – the subtle distinction in title is a result of medieval bickering over precedence…
Then the Church in Wales has an Archbishop (who is elected, and may be Bishop of any of Welsh dioceses); and the Church of Ireland has the Archbishop of Armagh – I guess he counts, though his jurisidiction also extends to Eire.
Strangely, the Episcopal Church of Scotland has a Primus (not a camping stove, though it may have one of those too for post-service coffee) – a sort-of-almost-Archbishop, also elected from among the diocesan bishops.
I make that 4 1/2 serving Anglican Archbishops, plus the 3 RC Abps (Westminster, St Andrews & Edinburgh, and Armagh) and sundry Abps of independent churches.
Incidentally, you may be aware of the shorthand of using a + to indicate a bishop, so our diocesan is +Martin. Some people (esp online) use ++ for an Archbishop and +++Justin for Canterbury!

If this carries on we’ll end up with a four cross Archbishop, equal only in rank to top US generals…

that will allow grace to enter where before there was the assumption of law, which is always something to be celebrated.

Immediarte reaction was ‘I love the sentence and the sentiment’ – and the next moment I find that its powerful challenge had slipped in under my lowered guard! Not quite what I expected when I began to read your post but ….Thank you!

Yeah, that kind of took me unawares too – it took me until halfway through the post to realise what the question was actually about, and if I ever get round to editing things then the silliness may well be trimmed a little.
Thank you.

No – the silliness is also part of the power of the punchline I think – takes the reader of their guard and then you get your whammy line in at the end before they can ‘raise shields’ and avoid the challenge!
Good rhetorical tactics :-D

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.