(subject courtesy of Aaron Parsons)
Ermmm.
Tricky.
My initial response is to say that God in his entirety was dead.
Then I remember that on the cross, Jesus says “My God! My God! Why have you forsaken me?!” which indicates that there was some kind of separation within the Trinity – unless this was just complete brokenness, and he felt forsaken of and in himself?
In Acts 2.24, Peter says that “God [we assume, ‘The Father’ raised him [definitely Jesus] from the dead.” Which indicates that the Trinity had somehow broken down during the crucifixion, only to be made (more?) complete when Jesus returned to the Godhead, taking humanity with him at the Ascension?
So, in answer to your question – I don’t know. It may well be that the concept of the Trinity in any case is our best guess at ‘how God works’ and and it’s certainly the case that there was more going on than we can get our ‘puny human’ minds around – at least at this time of night.
49 replies on “What Happened to the Trinity when Jesus Died?”
Sorry – I just realised I missed off two of your questions:
Actually, I think I have addressed the first. On the second – I dont think I would frame it in the same way. It is not so much that death has to be overcome as that we have to die…..metaphorically and, eventually, literally. IOW I can’t overcome death – in the sense of changing (‘improving’ if you want to stick this within perfection language) – unless I am prepared to die; that is unless I am prepared to let go of whatever it is (an attitude, a habit, an idea, a trait, a resentment, an anger…whatever) that is blighting the kind of life I aspire to live in the light of God’s love. But sometimes I don’t want to let go – I’d rather keep my resentment and knaw it over in the dark, I’d rather put my own comfort in a situation first. THAT is the sting of death – and it can only be drawn if I am willing to ‘die’ in that regard. Sometimes death is freely chosen, sometimes it comes to us whether we will or no……. but it CAN be overcome and this is where my earlier comment about the economy of God fits in. My battles with death and dying may be intensly, horribly painful experiences – but they need not be unredeemable ones (NB this is NOT the same as saying that suffering is sent by God/ennobles the soul – which are doctrines I strongly repudiate!)
This too is very well put indeed. And I too think you addressed the first.
And so rather belatedly to your further comments and questions …….
Firstly tho, can I just say that I neither have, nor pretend to, any great wisdom or special insight in any of this….I’m simply thinking out loud and feeling my way as I go: my own description of the journey of faith is that it is ‘an unsafe voyage to an unknown end’ and i long ago gave up the notion of thinking that I would ever have anything other than provisionally held ‘explanations’ , and what seems to me to make sense in the light of my current understandings and experiences may make less sense in times to come. I have a lodestar and various touchstones for my Christian faith, and I try to find my way using those rather than the prescriptive doctrinal maps I once used for my chief navigational aid.
Cutting to the chase then – and not necessarily in order of importance – my responses are thus: I still want to argue the toss with you on the hockey analogy! My point was, and still is, that even though you may not have the same genetic endowment as Mr Middleton, neverthless he excels by virtue of his human genetics, notbecause of some added extra ingredient,; whereas Jesus, in your scenario, appears to triumph because he is essentially other than human.
I’m also – and I think Rachel’s observations are relevant here- interested as to why you frame the issue in terms of ‘perfection’, of achieving (or the impossibility of achieving) a ‘perfect life’. Or rather, I’m interested in what appears to be your implicit framework for defining what ‘a perfect life’ consists of – and I think this is also something I would want to challenge (tho obviously NOT in a belligerent way! :-) ) IOW, we seem to be getting stranded here because the implicit assumption is that the kind of ‘perfection’ which God is looking for is defined in terms of being ‘sinless’ (and where of course sin and sinless are themselves defined in a very particular way which is constrained by the whole penal substitution/sacraficial atonememnt reading of the cross) . But if we look at how the OT Biblical texts and the teaching of Jesus himself define the kind of life which pleases God, we get a rather different picture I’d suggest: Do justly, love mercy, walk humbly with God, defend the widow and orphan, care for the stranger in your midst, feed the hungry, clothe the naked, tend the sick, visit the imprisonned, don’t take more than you need,share what you have, love God, love others, love yourself, be faithful to the teaching you received, walk in the light of the love you have experienced etc etc.
So then we might come to a diiferent understanding of temptation and sin – and if you look at the temptations of Jesus then perhaps one can see that there also: Thus if I take Jesus’ sinlessness as being that he faithfully did these things, despite the cost (ultimate cost in his case), and if he did this in his humanessrather than because of his divinity (and after all, it does appear to be cheating somewhat to live as God requires and claim it as an exemplar when you ARE God!) then it gives me hope that I too can faithfully follow the Divine imperative to love God and love my neighbour – even if that comes at a cost. So for me it is not about achieving some sort of mythical ‘sinlessness’ as defined in the ‘filthy rags’/’miserable worm’/’intrinsically corrupt by virtue of being human’ framework which I reject as being a later overlay of interpretation; it is about striving to live out the divine imperative to be relationally connected in a shalomic way – to God, to myself, to the Other, to my community, to the created order of the natural world – with all the moral and ethical imperatives that entails. Does that make sense?
In answer to your explicit questions – and briefly because otherwise this could be a very lengthy response (but as always, happy to expand further in follow-up conversation). You asked
I am not saying ‘Jesus was simply human’ Period! I am saying that my understansing is that when God becomes incarnate, part of the deal is that he voluntarily places restrictions on himself – we don’t have any difficulty accepting that the incarnate Jesus is not omnipresent after all, and to that I would add, is also neither omniscient nor omnipotent. I trace this understanding back to the Christological hymn in Philippians 2:5-11 (which is a pretty early text) and its dramatic but opaque assertion that Christ ‘emptied himself’. Kenotic theologies have a long pedigree in Christian thinking and have taken various forms….my own is influenced by thinkers such as Sergius Bulgakov and Hans Urs von Balthasar (though I don’t agree with everything they say by a long chalk!). So, I am able to believe that Jesus as incarnate was still in an important sense ‘divine’ but that he (paradoxically) uses the freedom which this entails to voluntarily restrict the freedom it confers – thus he truly is able to experience life ‘in the flesh’ just as we do…..there is no appeal to special knowledge or power……only the will to do what the love of God dictates that he do in terms of his life choices.
As regards ‘what hope of God acting incarnationally in our lives’ , I think I would turn this round and say that (just as with Jesus in a sense – tho it is slightly different because he was God!) it is through our lives that God is incarnated now. I’m not sure if that will make sense to you so I’ll also give it to you in the form of a hymn I wrote for my daughter’s confirmation – or at any rate, here’s the last verse:
This. All of this. You make much sense, Pat. And I need to look up kenotic now… *rubs hands with glee*
Thanks Rachel – and happy kenotic digging :-) If you’ve never come across it, you might enjoy ‘Love’s Endeavour, Love’s Expense’ by Cannon Bill Vanstone. I don’t know that he ever uses the word kenosis, but this was an early pointer towards kenosis for me and though I don’t now agree with everything he says, I still find it a beautiful, moving and challenging book on the creative response of God’s love. Another good book for exploring kenotic themes (without being too overpoweringly densly theological is ‘The Work of Love’ – edited by John Polkinghorne – which is a collection of short essays by scientists, philosophers and theologians on the kenotic view of creation.
The Classical view of an immutable God began to become increasingly untenable to me quite a few years ago, so discovering kenotic theologies was a real help to me in my thinking about how to develop an understanding of a God who could create, interact with and also become incarnate within the created order.
:oops: that’s ‘canon’ rather than cannon – obviously!
Nonono get that monster back in its box Rach. Appreciate your contribution to this discussion; please don’t duck out. Apologies for giving you the impression you weren’t welcome – sorry. Nothing could be further from the truth.
In particular, your comments about perfectionism as opposed to living a full life are very pertinent to me so thank you. Also, Dr. Suess for the win!
The context stuff above was meant to inform you more of previous discussion betw me and Pat so that you could comment in the light of that. It wasn’t meant to make you feel excluded; please forgive me.
Ah. *sheepish face* So I was probably a bit down and misinterpreted that context as a polite ‘yeah, you don’t quite get it, do you?’ but thankfully you were being much more gracious than that. D’oh. Not your fault, I’m going to blame t’internet and lack of audible tone. Glad I am not interrupting. I just really don’t want to make you feel I was trying to fix everything, ‘cos that’s annoying! Anyway, thanks for your kind words.
Moving swiftly on… Er…I don’t really anything new to add at this stage. Yes. I agree it’s a good thing to both be oneself contendedly, on the one hand, and at the same time try to improve oneself.
What I think is… It’s not that we shouldn’t ‘be good’, in a sense (i.e., good is still good, even if we’ve come to associate holiness with stale prudishness, say ), just that maybe thinking about trying to achieve perfection, especially on our own and in an ‘aaargh, I can never be perfect but I have to try’ sort of panicky way is at least counterproductive and probably missing the point.
Not that I necessarily pay anything more than lip service to these theories in everyday life, you understand.
Anyway. I’ll go and procrastinate elsewhere while we await Pat’s wisdom.
Sorry – been away for 12 days walking the Coast to Coast. Belatedly catching up with stuff but as it is now rather late (or rather, rather early!) I’ll sleep on this and reply when more awake :-)
OK. I apologize if I have been intruding/treading on your toes/sticking my oar in and disrupting the discussion or other similar metaphors. I also wouldn’t want to come across like I’m trying to say the answers to your questions are obvious and/or that you’re silly or whatever. I get the fleeing evangelicalism feeling where often doubt and questioning are maligned ‘cos everything’s supposed to be sewn up in a neat little watertight worldview, and I realise me saying ‘well duh, but OF COURSE you’re not supposed to be Jesus’ might not have been helpful. So yeah, sorry if I’ve been doing that/saying the obvious. Shall leave you to it! Peace out.
I don’t want to be Barry Middleton; have you seen his interviews? DULL. I want to be Greame Swann, except playing hockey cos its funner than cricket.
No seriously, i’m mostly ok with being myself, but I would like to get better at it (just like I want to get better at hockey) and I’ve been told occasionally that following Jesus might have something to do with achieving that aim (the first one I mean; not sure Jesus ever played hockey. His loss.)
But yes, its good to be reminded its not my job to be Jesus. And yes, life to the full is about relating beautifully, not being a prude.
The context to the questions Pat and I have been posing to each other is that we are both refugees from certain evangelical theologies (including the implied ‘you are a snivelling wretch’ one that you (Rachel) quoted Pat debunking above). The thing about fleeing from such things is that you have to work out which direction to flee in and then where you have ended up. Pat and I seem to make a habit of rejecting the same things but moving away from them in opposite directions, and this makes our discussions about where we’re at very fruitful (for me at least) because it feels (to me) like we have an empathy for the conflict (and, yes, paradox =] ) that each of us is experiencing, but the ability to critique (from the outside) the positions we might be thinking about taking up instead.
Firstly: having read what Pat says above a number of times in order to get my little brain to follow, I think I now understand and agree! :) Particularly this bit: “if Jesus does this [experiences life as a human and doesn’t ‘fail’] without having recourse to some added advantage (being God!) which I can never access, but simply as one living in the knowledge and light of relationship with God, then this tells me that it is possible to live as God intends – or at any rate, that it is possible to move closer to that state, and that I can do so. In other words, it doesn’t leave me with a picture of myself as somehow intrinsically flawed/evil/corrupt -i.e as by nature incapable of doing this.” Yep.
So secondly and relatedly: sure, some people are better at certain things than others, obviously, and no, we are probably often genetically/physically/naturally just not cut out for X thing, e.g. athleticism, singing. But we have other strengths and skills and tasks to do. We can’t all be hockey players – we shouldn’t be. It’d be very boring, and who’d drive the buses, etc?
You’re not Barry Middleton, I’m not Lauryn Hill (however cool that would be) or whoever – but, I find myself replying, why would we want to be someone else? I understand the admiration for/envy of someone else’s talents – but still. Besides, people will have been admiring or jealous of us too.
In the immortal words of Dr Seuss: “There is no one alive who is Youer than You.” You are you, and that’s fine – that’s ‘very good’, in fact, says God. I wonder if you’re looking at it a bit glass-half-empty: so you can never be as good as Barry Middleton (I have to confess I keep wanting to type Barry Scott and it’s SO ANNOYING) at playing hockey. BUT no-one else can ever be as good at being you as you can be.
So – you can’t be Jesus (and that’s fine; you just AREN’T, it’s not your job to be!), but you can be as you as possible– life to the full. I think this is what Pat is saying in the bit I quote above, reworded to see if I did understand.
Perhaps therefore, asking about ‘perfection’ is a bit of a red herring/the wrong word, and it’s more about living fully rather than trying REALLY HARD not to be naughty/a failure.
Perhaps. That’s what I reckon, anyway.
Pat – I think my analogy holds because International hockey players are genetically different to me, not just people who are training harder (though they do that too). OK, I get your point; they’re not aliens with superhuman abilities. But they are humans with abilities that *I don’t have, won’t ever have and can’t hope to get just by trying harder*
I have to accept (and this is hard for me) that *by nature* I am never gonna be able to play hockey for GB. I just don’t have the natural ability to do so (yes i’d be a helluva lot better if I trained more, worked harder at getting fit etc etc, but still). (And Rachel, this is where Miss Bennett and I must part company – sacrilege I know; some people are just better than others at certain things. Which is not to excuse Colin Firth for not trying – he’s wrong too.)
So I can’t meet the required standard to play for GB. More than that, the fact that certain other people *do* play hockey for GB does not change the fact that *I can’t*.
In fact it might almost make it harder; because i’m tempted to beat myself up for not matching their achievements (even though, genetically, I never could have).
If Jesus lived a perfect life, so what? I still can’t/don’t. The fact that Barry Middleton is very good at hockey has very little impact on my team unless he comes and plays for us. (Sure he’s a good example to watch from a great distance, but that’s all).
I sincerely hope that I can improve at hockey, but i’m not gonna play for GB. Trying to follow Jesus’ example will help us get better at living life, but it won’t make us perfect.
The question is does that matter?
And here’s where I poke you back (with all the same caveats):
If Jesus is to all intents an ordinary human and was perfect, then can we in fact be perfect? And what’s our excuse for not being?
For “new life to begin in the graveyard” (and I *so* agree and you phrased it *so* beautifully) then death has to have been overcome in some way. Agree or disagree? Metaphorical death/decay in our lives or actual Death death?
(And this one feels like its below the belt so please forgive me and take a swig of the honey vodka before reading on and know it’s a question asked with love and respect) If Jesus is an ordinary human, in what sense is he incarnational? (don’t say paradox =P). And if Jesus is human as we are human then what hope of God acting incarnationally in our lives/circumstances/whatever can we derive from his life? (FWIW I really believe the answer is definitely not “we can’t”).
(Pat, your answer is en route, but is taking longer!)
Tardy response? *This* is a tardy response!
Rachel – I agree that many hockey teams and many churches alike would benefit from a deeper understanding of the concepts of both discipleship and community. Less concern about achieving the immediate task at hand and beating the opposition and more about providing support for each other and helping each individual to develop is absolutely where I’m at (and what i’m often disillusioned by the lack of) in both cases.
Hi Linus and Rachel.
Apols for tardy response but I’m slogging away to meet a deadline so am a little squeezed timewise.
Linus – while I agree that somethings obviously do have paradoxical elements, I guess my point was more that this shouldn’t be the first court of appeal, or deter us from doing some digging – both of which I think are reflex positions which are sometimes adopted rather too easily by we Christians in the face of difficulties – suffering and ‘unanswered’ prayer come immediately to mind as archetypal examples (just to emphasise here – I’m not saying that you do this, just making a general point ) .
I’m afraid though that I think your hockey analogy is faulty – at least as regards the original point at issue (though I think it has utility in other directions, and in this respect, I like the points Rachel makes about teamplay etc). But with Barry Middleton we are talking about a difference of degree, not a difference of kind. IOW ithere is no in principle reason why you too could not attain that level of skill with better coaching/more practice (and ok, maybe a different genetic makeup in the lottery of birth, but this would still essentially be human). But if Jesus, playing under the same human rules, can only win , not because he is better but because he is different – which is what you are actually saying though I think you try and blur it by altering the terminology :-) then I cannot see how this gives me grounds for genuine hope – or rather, to reiterate my original question – I do not know what you are saying it gives me hope about
And for me, this ties in with your question
because for me, the hope would be in the fact that Jesus experienced human life – just as I do and yet didn’t ‘fail at it’ as I do ; and if Jesus does this without having recourse to some added advantage (being God!) which I can never access, but simply as one living in the knowledge and light of relationship with God, then this tells me that it is possible to live as God intends – or at any rate, that it is possible to move closer to that state, and that I can do so. In other words, it doesn’t leave me with a picture of myself as somehow intrinsically flawed/evil/corrupt -i.e as by nature incapable of doing this. So for me, that is a cause of genuine hope. I don’t expect to siucceed – but not because it is in principle impossible. And the message of the gospel is that in the economy of God, my failures need not be wasted but can become a means by which I move closer to that intent – new life begins in the graveyard over and over again. Does that make sense?
Linus, Pat, (Tim – sorry in advance!) hope you don’t mind me throwing my few pence in… I subscribed to get notified of replies to the comments in just my bit of the discussion and ended up being sucked into this very interesting discussion!
Firstly, really liked the hockey analogy (I do enjoy a good analogy, as is probably evident). Found it a really helpful way to look at it actually. I find there can be a temptation to beat oneself up for not being (able to be) as good as Jesus and therefore despairing somewhat, which when you put it like that seems very silly (but which of course doesn’t stop me). It is a team sport, and we’re not alone in the pursuit of, well, whatever success may be in either case.
However, that brings me to the thing I wanted to say. You’ve probably thought of this, and I may be getting the wrong end of the hockey stick, but here goes anyway…
I notice you say ‘I don’t want Jesus to be more like me’…’he needs to be inherently better than me to win under those rules’. Right, sure, you don’t want Jesus/Barry ‘dragged down to your level’ as it were, as that would help nobody, but do you not at all want to get closer to theirs? No, you will never be Jesus and you may never be as good as Mr. Middleton at hockey, but that doesn’t (I hope and suspect) prevent you trying to improve your game and ability and/or keep playing. And surely, if you had Barry on your team (or even anyone else with a different skill level – we can learn from others too), an advantage of this, apart from going ‘yay, I’m part of a winning team’ (nice though that is), is that you could learn from him, observe what he does right, maybe get his help personally to improve your technique.
Otherwise, (taken to an extreme perhaps but I hope you see my point) you could say we all might as well stop bothering making any sort of effort, right? If we’re never going to be like Jesus.
Unless…
Also, who’s to say Barry Middleton wouldn’t want to play on your team because of, say, your supportive team atmosphere or superior sense of humour, or because he just wanted to have some mates to have fun with? (Ah, that last reasons rings a bell…) “It’s not about the winning, it’s about the taking part”?
Does that make sense?
(This makes me think of a quote from the ever wonderful Jane Austen in Pride & Prejudice:
“I certainly have not the talent which some people possess,” said Darcy, “of conversing easily with those I have never seen before. I cannot catch their tone of conversation, or appear interested in their concerns, as I often see done.”
“My fingers,” said Elizabeth, “do not move over this instrument in the masterly manner which I see so many women’s do. They have not the same force or rapidity, and do not produce the same expression. But then I have always supposed it to be my own fault—because I would not take the trouble of practising. It is not that I do not believe my fingers as capable as any other woman’s of superior execution.”
Not quite the same perhaps, but made me think of it because Elizabeth is gently trying to make a point that Mr. Darcy’s defeatist attitude to his own social inhibitions aren’t going to help him. She knows she isn’t the best at piano playing, or even perhaps that good at all, but she does it anyway. They are no different in the fact that they are flawed, but there is a difference in how they are dealing with it. Where would we be if we all only did things we were good/better than others at?)
Here endeth the essay.
No fear re caveats; welcome your help exploring these subjects. And I’m sure Tim likes the attention too.
In this case my talking about paradox was part of stating the ‘problem’, rather than an ‘excuse’, and I agree that when ‘Its a paradox’ is used to shut down a debate or used without further elaboration its a total cop-out. I would say, however, that life does seem to be inherently paradoxical, or at least counter-intuitive; I suspect any worldview one explores for long enough will reveal paradoxical elements. And these can be part of their structure, not (always) just signs of flaws.
I often see my hockey playing as a metaphor for life. I play a lot of my hockey in the lowest organised league of the most underdeveloped region of the country, so you can draw your own conclusions as to our ability. Now if you were to drop Barry Middleton, the Eng & GB captain into our team, he would be not like us; he’d be good! He’s still playing the same sport under the same rules but he can do stuff with a hockey ball we can only dream of, and his inherent athletic ability, hand eye co-ordination etc means he is inherently better than me, even before getting to things like training, experience, determination, effort etc. His presence would singlehandedly take a mediocre, very fallible team and turn us easily into champions at this and several higher levels. And it would be his presence alone that would do that – we couldn’t achieve that ourselves. But Barry Middleton, though excellent, is not perfect. GB are a great team, but they’re not (yet) the best team in the world, let alone infallible. I want my hockey heroes to get better – to be *less* like me, not more, so that they can win, and as a member of England hockey, and as supporters of the national team, my club can feel like a tiny part of that victory.
In the same way, I don’t want Jesus to be more like me; I am very fallible. He needs to be playing by the same rules, yes, but he needs to be inherently better than me to win under those rules. And I need him to win so that I can throw in my lot with him and share in that victory. If God experiences human life and fails at it, like me… Where does that leave us? (genuine question)
Which I suppose leads on to the question of what is succeeding and failing at life?
Well Jesus defines Eternal life as knowing God, and so if we theorise that success at life is to have a perfect relationship with God and, as a result of that, perfect harmony within oneself – I think that is going some way to understanding what Christians claim that Jesus has achieved.
Linus – I hope you will already know this anyway, but for the benefit of anyone reading who doesn’t know me, further pushing from me here, and the way I choose to couch it, is not an indication of either hostile intent or negative feelings towards Christianity. Simply, this is one of the ways I try to tease out the hidden implications of my/our professions of faith so that I can see whether it reallyis what or how I believe/experience God to be, and whether that is something I would be happy to offer to someone else as ‘this is something woth living/dying for’. So in asking you more, I am also asking myself more – not saying ‘inadequate answer – must do better!’ :-)
Anyway, lenthy preamble over (and sorry Tim for writing screeds on your page!) My response to yours would be that claiming it as ‘a paradox’ might be open to the charge of just ducking the issue! And it also could simply sound as though God is pulling a fast one – being human enough to suffer some discomfiort through temptation – and so able to make a claim of ‘experiencing what it is like to be human’ -whilst all the while knowing that ‘Godness’ would prevent actual succumbing – a sort of spiritual ‘have your cake and eat it’ scenario. My question would be directed at your comment that
If Jesus’ unlikeness to me is what allows him to resist temptation, and if that unlikeness inheres in the fact of his being divine – then in what sense can it offer me ‘genuine hope’ since I am NOT divine and never will be (or at least, if we want to quibble, not as long as I am mortal flesh!) So what does it offer me genuine hope about? And in what sense is that different/more tangible than hope which might have already been offered in a more general way (say through the Hebrew scriptures)? Does that make sense?
I absolutely agree that it had to be possible for Jesus to run away with the butcher’s daughter, or indeed just run away (and who could blame him), otherwise the whole thing is a sham.
The paradox is that Jesus’ experience has to be similar enough to ours so that God can claim to have experienced what it is like to be human, to be able to sympathise with us in our weakness; but at the same time Jesus has to be more than a good man? I know several good men and they are, despite their goodness, deeply fallible and certainly incapable of bringing overarching hope to a fallen world. The human-ness of Jesus is important, but if Jesus is also God, that is surely of supreme importance? Jesus has to be sufficiently like us to be human, but sufficiently unlike us to offer us genuine hope.
Yeah, I was dimly aware of these concerns as I wrote… I think Jesus is a bit of a special case in that we are given to understand he pre-existed his body in a way we don’t.
As for how the ‘spiritual realm’ relates to the material one, I tentatively understand the material realm to be a sub-set of the spiritual realm, sustained within and existing as a part of the larger spiritual realm; everything is sacred. So a similar model to a secular materialist imagining our universe existing within a larger multi-verse, only I hypothesise that this larger realm contains sentient beings.
So.. I can see we have the seeds of an intersting discussion here :-) Do you think Jesus’ self-consciousness was different from ours then? IOW when he was a babe and a child was he conscious of his ‘God-ness’ (for want of a better way of putting it) ? And did he have a different awareness of/knowledge about the world than his playmates would have done?
No idea. Have you seen the film dogma? Really interesting line in it where one of the characters describes having to tell the young JC his identity/destiny. Gets me every time. Remember a debate with ppl at uni as to whether Jesus knew what was going to happen around the crucifixion and specifically resurrection in advance or not.
The gospel narratives claim Jesus was talking of God as his Father in quite an intimate way by age of 12. Beyond that, I wouldn’t want to say more. What are your thoughts?
Please consider this reply an acknowledgement of having read the discussion so far and of an honest intention to respond properly (probably in an actual post) at some point, but not just now.
Very interesting all round.
I’ve never seen Dogma – but will add it to my ‘things to do post-thesis’ list.
My own (provisional) understanding is that, no Jesus didn’t have any special ‘added extra’ consciousness/knowledge etc…whatever he came to understand about himself and his purpose, came through the experiences of and interactions he has with God as a ‘fully human’. And I think one can trace a developing undertsanding of various dimensions of that through the Gospel stories – think for example of his actions at the wedding in Cana, or his conversation with the syro–phonecian woman…they both give him a space in which he can explore and develop his understannding of his ‘mission’ (don’t really like the word – but that’s another conversation!). For me this would all fit into a kenotic framework of understanding – that the Incarnation requires some voluntary self-limitation on the part of Jesus..and that this is a real restriction. Thus for example, it must have been possible for Jesus to sucumb to the temptations offered by Satan in the wilderness (whether one sees this as an actual one off event or as standing for the fact that Jesus was tempted as part of his incarnate existence) – because if he wasn’t, it surely makes a mockery of any claim that Jesus was ‘tempted just as we were, yet without sin’, indeed of the whole Incarnational claim.
You must see it.
Linus – possibly I should be asking you this on your own blog rather than Tim’s but…in what sense do you distinguish ‘the spiritual element’ from the rest of ‘the package’ and how do the two connect up (that could be a physics question or a metaphysics question i guess – as the fancy takes you!)
Good question!
I’m not entirely sure that the spirit/body division is one I’m comfortable with – it sounds a lot like “he’s only mostly dead” – I’m going to have to do some head-hurting reading off the back of this…
I’ll come clean and say that it no longer makes any sense to me to think of a soul as some kind of alien entity inserted into my body when I’m born (or conceived or whatever one’s particular take on timing of ensoulment is’ and then wings it’s way elsewhere when I die. For one thing, I think it makes a mockery of the whole notion which one gets from both creation and Incarnation that God values and is committed to the world of matter, the world of the flesh. So, what ever I have that is worthy of the name of a soul is formed and shaped here by ‘this life I now live in the flesh’……
Yes, the idea that the body is just the shell for the real me doesn’t sit right. Yes, we’re a blend of flesh and spirit but it’s this blend that is us rather than just the body or just the spirit…
Nor does it sit Wright with Tom. Right?
He may have had some hand in the formation of my thinking…
So if Jesus was God in human form, the death of the human form – the body – doesn’t mean the spiritual element of the package ceases to exist. And the same is true of human beings if we are indeed ‘amphibious beings’ as C.S. Lewis describes us – partly made up of the material universe around us, and partly made up of something from a reality bigger than and different to the material world.
Yeah, I’d have said pretty much that. (Which obviously means it’s right.*)
I gather that, as you acknowledge, Tim, however much one tries, we can’t ultimately capture the true or entire breadth of God in our limited language, let alone minds, and that this is evident particularly often with regards to discussing/attempting to describe the nature of the Trinity. And that that seems to be the only thing you CAN say with any certainty without falling into heresy/losing your balance a bit – we know [enough to know] that we don’t know [enough]. Not so much nailing jelly to the wall as trying to pin down wind. There being ‘no-one like our God’, I suppose all metaphors/analogies/pictures/whathaveyous will inevitably fall short and be in some way inaccurate, however helpful they may be to get a little more of a snapshot of God in our puny human minds, as you so wonderfully put it. He [/She/they/the Trinity – we need a divine pronoun, really, like in Chinese] = God, we = not. And that’s fine by me. It’s nice that God isn’t squashable (technical term) into our neat little paradigms. I feel blogposty thoughts brewing along those lines…
Anyway, that’s enough theological waffle from me for one morning. I only came to say good question and good answer and got carried away. D’oh.
*not necessarily
Thanks Rachel – I look forward to reading whatever you come up with. I like the idea of a divine pronoun, because I’ve got to the point that I notice when I use “he” all the time but I’m not yet comfortable using “she” interchangeably – at least partly because I think that that kind of thing needs flagging up at the beginning of a bit of writing more so than going with the traditional ‘he’ – does that make sense?
I had half a post jotted down, need to fettle it somewhat, but you’ve spurred me on! When I get a mo/am next procrastinating maybe.
Yes, it’d be rather handy. Mind you, *puts linguist hat on (as if I ever take it off)* said pronoun might have to be singular and plural (again, not rly a problem in Chinese, the smug little non-conjugating language), so maybe it’s not so tenable. I suppose the best we could do to be correct in English would be to just use the word God/the Trinity in the same way we collectively use the word army or government, i.e. we can use it with ‘is’ or ‘are’. Mind you, that’s because we know those are a big single thing made up of plural individuals, so perhaps the same applies. Also, perhaps I need to stop thinking so deeply about the grammar… (don’t all agree at once).
So maybe if anything what we need to do more often is teach clearly that God is spirit and therefore not male or female (apart from Jesus incarnate, obvs), as you say, before we start a given sermon, and then get on with our lives.
Yeah, but the evidence of Jesus calling the Father ‘Father’ is used to (quite vehemently, more often than not) defend the majority of two thirds being revealed as male…
Looking forward to your post now.
I see your/that point (can’t tell if you’re agreeing or just devil’s advocating). But I’m not sure I can buy the idea that God is gendered per se – being spirit, and not, after all, like us, human and amphibious, except in Jesus on earth… I think (as does the Roman Catholic Catechism, I now read). Surely God is in a sense ‘beyond’ gender, and to say the Trinity is [more] male (or indeed female) would be to anthropomorphise God, who created (wo)mankind in imago Dei, not the other way round? Human/worldly metaphors can only ever imperfectly and indistinctly approximate a shadowy depiction of God. Another counterargument I can immediately think of is that God is called lots of things in the Bible, including being ascribed female and feminine characteristics (the topic of gender roles being a whole other debate, of course).
Plus, and quite significantly I think: God created us in God’s image/likeness, male AND female he created them. If God is 2/3 revealed as male, where does that verse fit in, and what might it be taken to say about women, the historically downtrodden sex? But I am something of an egalitarian/feminist so perhaps I would say that (though I prefer to think of it the other way round!) ;) Oooh, what a can of worms we have opened!
Anyway, that’s probably more than enough theological debate in one go. I don’t know enough about Theology, and as I mentioned before, most of what I do know/believe about the Trinity is that I don’t know everything. Which can be a relief!
xRx
PS fair warning, my forthcoming post’s only partly about the Trinity (sort of more the Spirit, perhaps), and not about gender, and it’s more poetic than the above essay, you may be relieved or disappointed to note!
But my puny human mind has now ceased to function, so I’m wimping out and going to bed
Good night! Thanks for your contributions…
There is perhaps a distinction to be made between Jesus, who humanly speaking was entirely dead, and God the Son who was fully present in Jesus, but did not/could not/does not die.
If God holds all creation in existence, then if God had died, creation would have ceased to exist.
Maybe – it still needs some thought, and I have little enough thought power left at the moment and several challenging posts still to write. Uptake has been somewhat more overwhelming than last time around…
Also, I LOVE it when the vicar/priest/person at the front says ‘Holy Ghost’ because I am a child.
Holy ghooooost.
Wooooo! Boo!
Holy Ghost.
Father, Son, Holy Spirit.
Coming from half and half parents (Mum was very religious when she was younger, My sister got that from her. Dad is an atheist and I guess I follow him. I am weird with my beliefs but that’s a blog post of my own… aaaanyway)
So yes, coming from a 1/2 and 1/2, having gone to Sunday School as a kid, and having a general interest in the world around me, you’d think I’d have a grasp on what the Holy Spirit actually constitutes.
I don’t. But it’s the kind of research that 1:05 am seems a grand time for.
Yay! It’s good to have you onboard! Thank you so much for your donation! I’ll endeavour to fit your topic in.
My favourite depiction of HS is that in nakedpastors cartoons – just makes me laugh every time I see it :-D
http://wp.patheos.com.s3.amazonaws.com/blogs/nakedpastor/files/2013/04/jesus-not-a-girl-550×550.jpg
The Naked Pastor is amazing!