Categories
Blogathon 2013

What are the indicators of success in a church?

(subject courtesy of Mark Elder)

First and foremost, I would say if people could work out that we were followers and friends of Jesus because of our love for one another, then that would be a fairly good indicator that we were ‘getting it right’.

Any church where the gospel is preached (and my definition of ‘gospel’ has broadened a whole hell of a lot over the years) is a church where the Spirit has a chance to live and breath and act and is therefore, to some extent a success.

I am wary of any attempts to measure a church in terms of success – these tend to be very quantitative tests – how many bums are we getting on pews, how heavy are the offering bags, and all of these things need measuring and responding to – but not as what makes the church successful.

It’s much harder to measure the qualitative things that show a church where God is allowed to be working – are people demonstrating the fruit of the Spirit, are people growing as disciples, are new friends being brought in (rather than do lots of people come because we have loud music), how welcoming is the church to outsiders, what sort of attitude does the surrounding community have towards the church, how about the authorities around the church?

I don’t believe in a Victorious Christian Lifestyle ™, any success is purely God’s but we can certainly stand in the way or help him along as he does what he does.

8 replies on “What are the indicators of success in a church?”

“Success indicators” make me wary. It smacks of management. As though God can be managed. There are plenty of churches who would be successful if based upon quantitative criteria.

One of the questions I would ask is “where do you sink you well”? A small faithful congregation who’ve sunk their well into the deep waters of God? A large congregation who’ve sunk their well into the oil fields of “measurable success”?

Swap the sizes around. It’s a metaphor not a successfully indicative, exhaustively quantifiable list.

Sounds good. And good topic, Mark!

I imagine you are probably heading to bed now for a well-deserved rest, but would be interested to hear you expand on the statement “my definition of ‘gospel’ has broadened a whole hell of a lot over the years” at your leisure (It looks like you’ve been given a nice wodge of writing topic ideas for the future throughout this blogathon!) if you would be so kind, as it’s summat I’ve bin pondering on and off for a while.

It really is a question of ‘choose your success metanarrative wisely’ isn’t it?! No scrub that – it’s more a case of ‘success metanarrtives are incommensurate with what the Gospel (like you, my understanding of that is considerably more expansive than was once the case) is about’

Maybe the best way is to ask, on a church by church basis – what is God doing here and how much are we on board with that?

I’ve read stories of churches that in closing down a particular congregation succeeded wildly in releasing God (another question – can we prevent God from acting?) into the situation in exciting ways that wouldn’t have otherwise been possible…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.