Stephen Moffatt should totally move on from Doctor Who. The Christmas Special was a horrible mess, and felt cobbled together out of old scraps of ideas rather than anything that had an ounce of thought put into it. It doesn’t even work very well as a two-parter with The Day of the Doctor – itself a bit of a mess but enjoyable all the same. I never want to feel like I’ve wasted an hour of my life watching Doctor Who. Horrible.
What would I have done differently?
Everything up to the crack in the wall with the Time Lords on the other side was fine (with the possible exception of Oswin not reacting murderously towards the Silence alien) but after that, Matt Smith’s Doctor should have had his final show down on Trensilore, given his life heroically in some way to get the crack closed and the Time Lords (who it must be remembered were last seen at the point of being equal-uber-villains in the Time War and equally responsible for the near destruction of life as we know it) sealed off to be brought back at a later date. And because he was the thirteenth Doctor (as Moffatt was splashing all over the press) no regeneration at all. We see the ruins of Trensilore with the dead TARDIS as a flashback to the series seven finale, with an accompanying flashback through the Doctor’s many lives. The end.
However, in a story presented in parallel with this: John Hurt’s Doctor, having made peace with himself and been joined in the ‘hand-on-the-button’ moment with two of his future selves showing their acceptance of his having to make the best of a bad bunch of choices, massively changing his own future development (no more brooding self-hatred – no matter how much the script said ‘I won’t remember this’ – something important changed and there’s no need for him to become the angst-filled Ecclestone incarnation) is shown regenrating into somebody with ‘less prominent ears’, namely the Capaldi Doctor and thus creating a new timeline altogether and setting up a Doctor without all the baggage that modern Who had accumulated since the relaunch, with three regenerations left to track down the sub-universe containing the Time Lords and either persuading them to give him another set of regenerations or giving it up as a bad show some time around 2025.